Vitamin E supplement
benefit, side effects, natural versus synthetic, dosage, food sources, Information
August 20 2018 by Ray Sahelian, M.D.
Also known as tocopherol, it was isolated in the 1920s. There is general agreement that this fat soluble oil can function as an excellent antioxidant protecting cells from damage. The discovery of vitamins was a major scientific achievement in our understanding of health and disease. In 1912, Casimir Funk originally coined the term vitamine. The major period of discovery began in the early nineteenth century and ended at the mid-twentieth century.
Vitamin E (α-tocopherol) was discovered nearly 100 years ago because it was required to prevent fetal resorption in pregnant, vitamin E-deficient rats fed lard-containing diets that were easily oxidizable. The human diet contains eight different vitamin E-related molecules synthesized by plants; despite the fact that all of these molecules are peroxyl radical scavengers, the human body prefers α-tocopherol. The biological activity of vitamin E is highly dependent upon regulatory mechanisms that serve to retain α-tocopherol and excrete the non-α-tocopherol forms. This preference is dependent upon the combination of the function of α-tocopherol transfer protein (α-TTP) to enrich the plasma with α-tocopherol and the metabolism of non-α-tocopherols. α-TTP is critical for human health because mutations in this protein lead to severe vitamin E deficiency characterized by neurologic abnormalities, especially ataxia and eventually death if vitamin E is not provided in large quantities to overcome the lack of α-TTP. α-Tocopherol serves as a peroxyl radical scavenger that protects polyunsaturated fatty acids in membranes and lipoproteins. Although specific pathways and specific molecular targets have been sought in a variety of studies, the most likely explanation as to why humans require vitamin E is that it is a fat-soluble antioxidant.
Synthetic vitamin E versus natural,
is there a difference?
On a supplement label
natural vitamin E is listed as d-alpha tocopherol. In contrast, synthetic
forms of vitamin E are labeled with a dl- prefix, dl-alpha-tocopherol. Many studies evaluating
the role of vitamin E in health and disease have focused mostly on
synthetic vitamin E supplements without the investigators recognizing that
health benefits could be different between the two. Also, some researchers do
not recognize the likelihood that several types of vitamin E substances are
beneficial, not just alpha tocopherol.
Advances in Nutrition 2017. Natural Forms of Vitamin E as Effective Agents for Cancer Prevention and Therapy. Initial research on vitamin E and cancer has focused on α-tocopherol (αT), but recent clinical studies on cancer-preventive effects of αT supplementation have shown disappointing results, which has led to doubts about the role of vitamin E, including different vitamin E forms, in cancer prevention. However, accumulating animal studies show that other forms of vitamin E, such as γ-tocopherol (γT), δ-tocopherol (δT), γ-tocotrienol (γTE), and δ-tocotrienol (δTE), have far superior cancer-preventive activities than does αT. These vitamin E forms are much stronger than αT in inhibiting multiple cancer-promoting pathways, including cyclo-oxygenase (COX)– and 5-lipoxygenase (5-LOX)–catalyzed eicosanoids, and transcription factors such as nuclear transcription factor κB (NF-κB) and signal transducer and activator of transcription factor 3 (STAT3). These vitamin E forms, but not αT, cause pro-death or antiproliferation effects in cancer cells via modulating various signaling pathways, including sphingolipid metabolism. The existing evidence strongly indicates that these lesser-known vitamin E forms are effective agents for cancer prevention or as adjuvants for improving prevention, therapy, and control of cancer.
Types of natural vitamin E
supplements
Several types are available, including alpha, beta, gamma and delta
tocopherol. Alpha-tocopherol
seems to be the most active, although we should not dismiss the importance of
the others. It seems prudent to supplement with natural vitamin E products that have mixed tocopherols
as opposed to just alpha tocopherol.
Tocotrienols
and tocopherols are potent antioxidants that are 100% natural.
MultiVit Rx
High Quality Daily Vitamins and Minerals with natural vitamin E complex
This
MultiVit Rx product
has 100 units of natural vitamin E complex of mixed tocopherols per serving.
Deficiency in the American diet
Adv Nutr. 2014. Vitamin E
inadequacy in humans: causes and consequences. It is estimated that more than
90% of Americans do not consume sufficient dietary vitamin E, as α-tocopherol,
to meet estimated average requirements.
Benefit of Vitamin E - synthetic or natural
The benefits are often debated in the medical community.
Much of the confusion is due to the fact that researchers have used and analyzed
different forms and different dosages. For instance, much of
the research regarding the benefit has been done with
synthetic vitamin E, specifically
dl-alpha tocopherol as opposed to natural alpha tocopherol. Making this
even more complicated, researchers have rarely analyzed the benefit of a
natural vitamin E complex that includes a mix of tocopherols and
tocotrienols. Hence, when you read a study that comments on the benefits and
risks of vitamin E supplementation, always look to see what form they are talking about.
Aging and anti-aging
Taking a high dose of vitamin E routinely does not increase your chances of
living longer, and in fact it seems to have a negative effect. Vitamin E
supplementation at doses higher than 400 International Units (IU) per day
apparently raises all-cause mortality rates and should be avoided. Because of its
antioxidant properties, vitamin E supplementation has been studied in many
trials to prevent chronic diseases. Several of those studies have hinted at
increased mortality rates, but the number of participants in the each study was
too small to tell if the results were real or occurred by chance. Dr. Edgar R. Miller III, at Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions in
Baltimore, pooled data from 19 trials.
These included nearly 136,000 subjects who were randomly assigned to take
vitamin E or placebo capsules and were followed for more than a year. Overall,
vitamin E supplementation did not affect mortality rates.
However, the 11 trials testing doses of 400 IU daily or higher showed 39 more
deaths occurred per 10,000 people taking high-dose vitamin E than among the same
number of people taking a placebo. For low doses of
vitamin E -- less than 150 IU daily -- all-cause mortality rates were slightly
decreased, although this difference was not significant from a statistical
standpoint. When the researchers factored in the simultaneous use of other
vitamins or minerals, the reduction in the risk of dying with low-dosage vitamin
E was toned down, but the risk at higher doses was increased. Annals of
Internal Medicine, November 10 online, 2004.
Dr. Sahelian says: I always thought that, for most
people, taking more than 100 to 200 units a day of vitamin E was not
necessary. The one problem with this study, though, is that it probably
did not make a distinction between synthetic vitamin E supplements and
natural vitamin E.
Also, the study did not account for the d-alpha form of vitamin E versus a
natural Vitamin E supplement that includes all the tocopherols and
tocotrienols. Even though it is a flawed study, I still think 30 to 200
units of vitamin E a few times a week is acceptable and perhaps
beneficial.
Alzheimer's disease
Dec. 31, 2013, Journal of the American Medical Association - A large
daily dose, 2,000 units a day for a period of 2 years, might help slow
progression of the memory-robbing illness. However, when used for decades, the
dose should be no more than 100 units a day, and I suggest using a mixed
tocopherol product.
May 2009 - Dr. Alireza Atri at Massachusetts General Hospital, the VA Bedford Medical Center, and Harvard Medical School, Boston, led a National Institutes of Health-sponsored research. Patients were given standard-of-care treatment with a drug intended to help with Alzheimer's. As part of their clinical care, 208 patients also took vitamin E but no anti-inflammatory meds, 49 took an anti-inflammatory med but no vitamin E, 177 took both vitamin E and an anti-inflammatory med, and 106 took neither. While the daily dose of vitamin E ranged from 200 to 2000 units, the majority of patients were given high doses that ranged from 800 units daily to 1000 units twice daily. After an average of 3 years, there was a modest slowing of decline in function in those taking vitamin E. Dr. Alireza Atri reports taking an anti-inflammatory medication was associated with only a small effect on slowing long-term decline in cognitive functioning. In patients who took both vitamin E and anti-inflammatory medications, there appeared to be an additive effect in terms of slowing overall decline.
Relation of the tocopherol forms to incident Alzheimer disease and to cognitive
change.
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
2005
High intake of vitamin E from food (tocopherol), but not from
supplements (which usually contain -tocopherol), is inversely associated with
Alzheimer disease. We examined whether food intakes of vitamin E, -tocopherol
equivalents (a measure of the relative biologic activity of tocopherols and
tocotrienols), or individual tocopherols would protect against incident
Alzheimer disease and cognitive decline over 6 y in participants of the Chicago
Health and Aging Project. Design: The 1993–2002 study of community residents
aged 65 y included the administration of 4 cognitive tests and clinical
evaluations for Alzheimer disease. Higher intakes of vitamin E and -tocopherol equivalents were
associated with a reduced incidence of Alzheimer disease in separate
multiple-adjusted models that included intakes of saturated and trans fats and
docosahexaenoic acid. - and -Tocopherol had independent associations. In
separate mixed models, a slower rate of cognitive decline was associated with
intakes of vitamin E, -tocopherol equivalents, and - and -tocopherols.
The results suggest that various tocopherol forms rather than -
tocopherol alone may be important in the vitamin E protective association with
Alzheimer disease.
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)
Regular users of vitamin E are at decreased risk for death from Lou Gehrig's
disease, also called amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), compared with
nonusers. Given that vitamin E is an antioxidant, the findings support the
hypothesis that oxidants play a key role in the development of ALS. Still, use of
another antioxidant, vitamin C, seemed to confer no protection against ALS, the
report in the Annals of Neurology indicates. In the study, Dr. Alberto Ascherio,
from Harvard School of Public Health in Boston, and colleagues analyzed data
from nearly 1 million subjects enrolled in the American Cancer Society Cancer
Prevention Study II. All of the subjects were at least 30 years of age when the
study began in 1982. Compared with nonusers,
patients who took vitamin E for less than 15 days per month did not reduce the
risk of death from ALS.
However, patients who used vitamin E for 15 or more days per month for at least
10 years had a reduced risk of ALS death. Vitamin C is "a water-soluble antioxidant with different properties than
vitamin E and thus may not" act the same in the body.
Annals of Neurology, 2004.
Antioxidant
I am 26 years old and just wanted to check can i
start using vitamin E supplements or will it create any problem in future.
I even wanted to confirm whether intake of this and other
antioxidants is beneficial or
harmful.
This is too broad a question and difficult to answer since each
person has a different diet, requirement, and there are many types of
vitamin E supplements and other vitamin products and antioxidants on the market with
different dosages.
Additional antioxidants that could
be taken with vitamin E:
Aceytylcysteine is
a potent antioxidant used to protect the liver from acetaminophen toxicity.
Acetyl l Carnitine is
an antioxidant and a mental stimulant.
Carnosine is an
antioxidant and improves energy levels.
Curcumin is a
spice that has become
very popular over the past few years.
Lipoic acid is often
used by those with diabetes.
Vitamin E and cataracts
A study from Sweden indicates that it can protect against cataracts
caused by ultraviolet radiation in laboratory rats. The study exposed two groups
of rats to ultraviolet light and found that the group given vitamin E developed
only slight opacities while the group deprived of it developed cataracts. Human
studies have not shown consistent results.
Vitamin
E and cancer prevention or treatment
Its role in
cancer is a hotly debated topic, and you
can find viewpoints on both ends of the spectrum, each quoting their own
facts and studies. Some researchers feel supplementation could
reduce the risk of certain cancers, while others disagree. There have been
many studies on this topic, yet no firm conclusions can be made
regarding their role cancer prevention. Part of
the problem lies in calculating or determining the ideal vitamin E dosage,
and also the form of vitamin E, whether natural or synthetic. I think low
dosages are helpful whereas too much can be counterproductive.
Taking high-dose vitamin E supplements for an extended period
doesn't protect against cancer; in fact, it may even speed up the development of
latent cancers. Researchers from Hotel-Dieu de Quebec
Research Centre and Universite Laval published their results in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute. Dr. Isabelle Bairati, professor at the Universite Laval Faculty of Medicine and researcher at
Hotel-Dieu de Quebec's Oncology Research Centre, conducted the study among 540
volunteers over an eight-year period. All the participants were treated for
early stage head and neck cancer and were at high risk of developing another
cancer. During the first three years, half of the participants received 400
international units of vitamin E daily, while the rest were given a placebo. In the three years during which participants
were given either vitamin E supplements or a placebo, researchers recorded more
cancer cases in the vitamin E group than in the placebo group.
In the period after the supplements were stopped, the situation was reversed:
more cancer cases were recorded in the placebo group than in the vitamin E
group. At the end of the eight-year period, the percentage of patients who
developed cancer was the same in both groups (30%). - Researchers suggest that
the use of vitamin E supplements may have sped up the development of latent
cancers in the patients who were part of the vitamin E group.
"This cancer chemoprevention trial was conducted in a population of patients at
high risk of second cancers. There is some concern about the generalization of
the study results to individuals in the general population who are at low risk
of a first cancer. Nevertheless, our results suggest that caution should be
advised regarding the use of high-dose vitamin E supplements for cancer
prevention," explained Dr. Isabelle Bairati.
Dr. Sahelian comments: I wish the researchers had used
a lower amount, such as 100 units -- and in the natural,
mixed form. Perhaps the results would have been much different.
Diabetes
A daily dose of vitamin E may help delay the onset of type 2 diabetes in people
at high risk of the disease. Researchers in New Zealand found that high-dose
vitamin E appeared to temporarily improve insulin resistance -- a precursor to
type 2 diabetes -- among 41 overweight adults. Though the improvement was
short-lived, another diabetes risk factor -- elevations in a liver enzyme called
alanine transferase -- changed for the better throughout the six-month study.
Some past studies have reached similar conclusions. A recent study found that
people whose diets had a healthy dose of antioxidants, including vitamin E, had
a lower diabetes risk than those with lower antioxidant intakes.
Heart disease
The role of vitamin E in
heart disease
is another hotly debated topic in the medical community, and again you can find
viewpoints on both ends of the spectrum,. Over the
years there have been several studies on the role of vitamin E in heart
disease, with some studies indicating that it could be helpful, whereas
other results have not been as promising. Part of the problem
lies in calculating or determining the ideal dosage, and the form.
Menstrual cramps
Women may find some relief from
menstrual cramps by taking vitamin E a few
days a month. A study of teenage girls in Iran found that those who took
it starting two days before their periods suffered less cramping than their
peers who used only standard pain medication according to Dr. Saeideh Ziaei and her colleagues at Tarbiat Modarres
University in Tehran. Common
menstrual cramps, or primary dysmenorrhea, are thought to result from the
release of hormone-like substances called prostaglandins which cause the uterus
to contract in order to expel the uterine lining, resulting in menstrual blood
flow. Vitamin E, by acting on two enzymes in the body, can inhibit the formation
of prostaglandins -- and, potentially, menstrual cramps. Girls in the vitamin E group took 200
milligrams (mg) of the vitamin twice a day, starting two days before they
expected their periods and continuing through the third day of menstruation.
Both groups were allowed to take ibuprofen if they needed to. British
Journal of Gynecology, April 2005.
Parkinson's disease
There may a potential for this nutrient to be of benefit in Parkinson's disease.
Vitamin
E and pregnancy
Women who've just become pregnant should be careful with their usage. It seems that high levels early in
pregnancy may increase
the risk of the baby being born with a heart defect. High levels
may cause an imbalance in the oxidant / antioxidant state in embryonic tissues. Other
possible mechanisms for the adverse effects of high vitamin E on the baby
include modification of genes involved in embryonic heart development and
inhibition of cellular enzymes involved in clearing away naturally occurring
toxins. International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 2009.
Prostate
cancer
Q.
What is your take on vitamin E and prostate cancer? Do you advise
discontinuing it's use? I read a study that followed up on men who took
high doses, 400 mg, of the vitamin daily for about five years found they had a
slightly increased risk of prostate cancer
— even after they quit taking the pills.
A. I am not a big proponent of high dose intake and don't think
people should take more than 100 units of vitamin E a day. However, this study
had two major flaws. One was the fact that the dosages of vitamin E given to
patients was very high at 400 units a day, and second it was in a synthetic form
as all rac-α-tocopheryl acetate as opposed to a vitamin E complex that includes
a variety of several natural forms of tocopherols and tocotrienols.
High blood levels of alpha- and gamma-tocopherol, seem to
cut the risk of prostate cancer by about 50 percent each. The findings are based
on an analysis of 100 individuals with prostate cancer and 200 cancer-free
"controls" participating in the Alpha-Tocopherol, Beta-Carotene Cancer
Prevention (ATBC) Study, which included nearly 30,000 Finnish men. Men with the
highest levels of alpha-tocopherol in their blood at baseline were 51 percent
less likely to develop prostate cancer than those with the lowest levels.
Similarly, men with the highest levels of gamma-tocopherol were 43 percent less
likely to develop the disease compared with men with the lowest levels. Further
analysis showed that the link between high tocopherol levels and low cancer risk
was stronger among subjects using alpha-tocopherol supplements than among
non-users. This supports the original findings from the ATBC study, which showed
that daily vitamin E supplementation reduced the risk of prostate cancer. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, March 2, 2005.
Vitamin E and scar formation, skin health
Some people think they break out with acne or pimples if they use vitamin
E oil or vitamin E cream or vitamin E gel on their face.
The effects of topical vitamin E on the cosmetic appearance of
scars.
Dermatol Surg. 1999. Baumann LS, Spencer J.
University of Miami Department of Dermatology and Cutaneous Surgery,
Miami, Florida
Anecdotal reports claim that vitamin E speeds wound healing and
improves the cosmetic
outcome of burns and other wounds. Our study shows that there is no benefit to
the cosmetic outcome of scars by applying vitamin E after skin surgery and that
the application of topical vitamin E may actually be detrimental to the cosmetic
appearance of a scar.
Vitamin E side effects, safety, caution, danger
Very high dosages, such as 1,000 units or more, can lead to an
increase in bleeding tendency, tiredness, weakness, headache, nausea, and possibly impaired immune
function. The benefit probably diminishes after a dosage of
200 units and side effects start after 1000 units. The side
effects go away relatively quickly after stopping the
supplement. It is nearly impossible to become vitamin E toxic from food
alone. An infrequent vitamin E side effect is allergy which may be in the
form of breathing difficulty and swelling of the lips, tongue or face.
As with any supplement, overdosage or taking too
much vitamin E is quite possible. Overdosage or toxicity with
vitamin E can lead to gastrointestinal disturbances, but I have not heard of
fatalities or any major and immediate danger from taking
too many vitamin E supplement pills.
Recommendations
The average American diet contains between 10 and 22 international units
of vitamin E. Additional intake may be beneficial. Most healthy adults
should do well with supplementing with 20 to 200 units of natural vitamin E
complex two or three times a week. I do not recommend daily doses
above 400 units. Since vitamin E is fat soluble, it need not be taken daily.
Avoid synthetic vitamin E supplements.
I am a nutritionist practicing in Chicago and came across an editorial in the American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition by Maret G Traber who is at the Linus
Pauling Institute at Oregon State University in Corvallis, OR. Here is the
last paragraph of the editorial: "And so we are left with the good news
that the serum concentration of {alpha} - tocopherol is associated with
decreased chronic disease risk, but we still do not know how much vitamin
E to recommend for consumption to achieve that concentration. It may be
that large vitamin E supplements are not necessary to achieve optimal
serum {alpha} - tocopherol concentrations, in that the
recommended dietary allowance of 15 mg per day may yield optimal serum
concentrations to achieve significant reductions in chronic disease
mortality. However, 15 mg a day may be an intake that is achieved
only with supplements, given the dietary habits of most Americans and the
observation that vitamin E–rich food sources are less popular foods, such
as nuts, seeds, and vegetable oils, including olive, sunflower, or
safflower oils.
A person's optimal vitamin E supplement requirement is
influenced by many factors, particularly diet. I think a vitamin E
supplement intake of 20 or 30 to 200 units a couple of times a week is reasonable, and
frankly I don't see the need to take megadoses beyond 200 to 400 units a
day.
Food sources
The food content of vitamin E is well known. Foods high in vitamin E
most commonly include wheat germ oil, almonds, sunflower seeds, whole
grains, wheat germ, spinach, and a number of oils.
Vitamin E Research
Vitamin E and respiratory tract infections in elderly nursing home
residents: a randomized controlled trial.
JAMA. 2004.
Vitamin E supplementation has been shown to improve immune response in elderly
persons especially if they have a deficiency. To determine the effect of 1 year of vitamin E
supplementation on respiratory tract infections in elderly nursing home
residents. A randomized, double-blind,
placebo-controlled trial was conducted at 33
long-term care facilities in the Boston, Mass, area. A total of 617 persons aged
at least 65 years and who met the study's eligibility criteria were enrolled. Vitamin E (200 IU) or placebo
capsule administered daily; all participants received a capsule containing half
the recommended daily allowance of essential vitamins and minerals. Supplementation with 200 IU per day did not have a statistically significant effect on lower respiratory
tract infections in elderly nursing home residents. However, we observed a
protective effect of vitamin E supplementation on upper respiratory tract
infections, particularly the common cold, that merits further investigation.
Vitamin E and CoQ10 work well together for heart and circulation
One of the early signs of vascular disease is inflammation within the walls
of the arteries. This inflammation attracts white blood cells and other
types of cells floating in the blood to the damaged inner lining of the arteries,
resulting in plaque formation and increased likelihood of clotting. The initial
inflammation and subsequent damage can result from a number of factors, including
oxidation or free radical damage, high cholesterol, and high homocysteine.
Researchers gave 21 baboons a
high fat, high-cholesterol diet (just like my Thanksgiving meal) daily for
7 weeks and measured the blood level of a substance you will hear of
more in the future called CRP, short for C-reactive protein. CRP is a
marker for inflammation. The higher the CRP, the more damage to the inner
lining of a blood vessel, like the coronary arteries in the heart. At the
end of the 7 weeks, they continued with this high fat, high cholesterol
diet, but this time they added vitamin E. The addition of vitamin E
reduced the level of CRP. Then they added COQ10 on top of the vitamin E
for another 2 weeks. They discovered that the levels of CRP dropped even
further. The researchers conclude, "Dietary supplementation with vitamin E alone reduces the
baseline inflammatory status that is indicated by the CRP concentration in
healthy adult baboons. Co-supplementation with CoQ10 significantly
enhances this effect of vitamin E."
Dr. Sahelian says: For those of you with a heart
condition or high cholesterol, or a family history of heart disease, it
would make sense to take vitamin E complex and CoQ10. Discuss with your
doctor if these are appropriate for your condition. A reasonable amount
would be 30 to 200 units daily of natural vitamin E complex, or 100 to 300 units two
or three times a week since vitamin E is fat soluble and can be stored in
fat cells. As to CoQ10, a range
of 20 to 60 mg is appropriate, a few times a week. CoQ10 is also fat
soluble and is best taken with breakfast. Vitamin E can be taken with any
meal.
Emails
Q. What is vitamin E oil used for?
A. I don't have a good understanding of vitamin E oil
at this time and don't have a good idea what benefit vitamin E oil can
have.
Q. Hi Dr. Sahelian, How are you? I hope all is well. I'm hoping you
could help me for an article I'm writing on anti-aging antioxidants for
Remedies magazine. I'm looking for someone to comment on vitamin E. Since
there is so much information (and misinformation) out there, I was
wondering if you could just offer a comment or two on your stance on
vitamin E. Does it work/not work, is it safe/unsafe? What role, if any,
does it play in anti-aging? I'd appreciate any help you could give me.
A. There is no proof as of now, that supplementing with
vitamin E has anti-aging benefits, but most of the research points to the
possibility that vitamin E supplements could have health improving
benefits, and maybe reduce the risk of heart disease and cancer. The ideal
dosage and frequency of intake is currently not known. Research does point
to the fact that high doses may be counterproductive. If someone were to
supplement with vitamin E, daily amounts should be less than 200 units,
and it is highly recommended that vitamin E be natural and include most of
the different forms of vitamin E, such as alpha, delta, gamma tocopherols,
etc since in foods we find many different forms. In my opinion, some of
the research with vitamin E has been flawed since scientists often
evaluated supplementation with only the alpha form, and excluded the rest.
In addition, the research sometimes focused on the synthetic form of
vitamin E, known as dl-alpha-tocopherol, as opposed to the natural form,
d-alpha-tocopherol. The outcomes may have been different if natural forms
of vitamin E were used rather than synthetic.
Additional articles of interest
Saw palmetto used for
bph
Pygeum is often found
together with saw palmetto in prostate formulas.
Tongkat ali herb
for sexual enhancement
Q. I recently came across your website and very much
appreciate your very objective and thoughtful commentary and recommendations. My
question is this: Is it possible to determine how much vitamin E is contained in
any particular softgel, given that the vitamin E d-alpha tocopherol component is
always given in IU but the gamma and other mixed tocopherols and tocotrienols
are given only in milligrams. I realize you can't apply the same conversion
formula, but is there some way to figure out approximately how much total
vitamin E one is getting in a given capsule? By way of context, my husband's
severe short term memory loss has not benefited from taking Aricept and Namenda.
Having read that high gamma vitmain E might have special benefits, I purchased
some Life Extension Gamma E Tocopheral / Tocotrienols full spectrum Vitamin E,
whose gelcaps contain 46 IU of D-alpha tocopherol and 325 mg of gamma E mixed
tocopherols (mainly gamma), plus 145 mg of tocotrienol complex. Since my husband
takes warfarin for his long standing lone atrial fibrillation (benign AF with no
underlying heart disease), I didn't want to exceed 400 daily IU of vitamin E.
When I called the company to ask how I could determine approximately how much
total vitamin E there was in one of the Life Extension softgels, I was told I
could get an approximation of the total IU by multiplying the milligrams of
gamma E mixed tocopherols and the totcotrienols by 1.49 and adding this to the
46 IU of D-alpha tocopheral. If this is correct, one capsule would contain 746
IU-- far more than 400 IU/day. However I later came across your excellent
website and you list a Now Foods Tocopherol Complex Vitamin E supplement, and
under Amount Per Serving, it says 15 mg of Gamma tocopherol equals 2.9 IU-- or
0.19 IU per milligram. And obviously there is a huge discrepancy between 0.19 IU
and 1.49 IU per milligram.
I realize you can't comment on what dosage or what particular composition of
vitamin E might be appropriate in my husband's case, but could you possibly
comment on the above discrepancy. And since others may be as confused as I,
could you indicate how one could determine approximately how much total vitamin
E one is getting in a given supplement, when the d-alpha tocopherol is given in
IU but the other components are given only in milligrams?
A. These are good questions. The exact potencies of different
tocopherols and tocotrienols as related to alpha tocopherol are difficult to
find and different research labs have come up with different numbers, but I came
across one source that appears to be reliable. It appears that one mg of alpha
tocopherol is equal to one iu of alpha tocopherol. The United States Department
of Agriculture conversion factors as reported by McLaughlin and Weihrauch are:
alpha-tocopherol = 1.00
beta-tocopherol = 0.40
gamma-tocopherol = 0.10
delta-tocopherol = 0.01
alpha-tocotrienol = 0.30
beta-tocotrienol = 0.05
gamma-tocotrienol = 0.01
Another source has conversion factors cited by McCance and
Widdowson. the vitamin E values are:
alpha-tocopherol = 1.00
beta-tocopherol = 0.30
gamma-tocopherol = 0.15
alpha-tocotrienol = 0.30
Therefore it appears that 1 mg of gamma tocopherol has similar
potencies to about 0.1 mg to 0.15 mg or 0.1 to 0.15 iu of vitamin E alpha
tocopherol.
Having said all this, it is important not to get bogged down in
details and lose sight of the overall picture. As a general rule it may not be a
good idea to consume more than 100 or 200 units of vitamin E a day. Therefore,
if a person is taking a supplement that has several hundred milligrams of
vitamin E, one option is to only take it a couple of times a week. Vitamin E is
fat soluble and can stay in tissues. Also, even though gamma tocopherol may be
less potent than alpha tocopherol, it may play a different role in the body that
could make it useful in ways that alpha tocopherol is not able to. In addition,
vitamin E studies have not shown consistent results in terms of effectiveness as
a treatment for short term memory loss.
Buy Natural Vitamin E supplement - Tocopherol Complex supplement, 60 softgels, Now Foods
Buy Vitamin E 100 iu
Supplement Facts | ||
Serving Size: 1 Softgel | ||
Amount Per Serving | %DV | |
Vitamin E (as d-Alpha Tocopherol plus d-Beta, d-Delta and d-Gamma Tocopherols) |
Use: As a dietary supplement, take one vitamin E softgel a few times a week with food. Since it is fat soluble and is stored if fat tissue in the body, it need not be taken every day. The RDA for vitamin E is about 15 units per day. It's quite possible that higher amounts could be more beneficial.
Products also available to buy online
Jarrow Formulas, Famil-E, 60 Softgels